Five good holes will work ok. If your tap broke while it was cutting the threads, it is probably tight. If it is above the surface any, you could try to work it out with some needle nose pliars that you can put a small piece of duct tape on each end to cushen the grip on the tap without breaking off pieces of it.
I have removed many taps that were broke while tapping aluminum with nitric acid. The acid eats away at the steel tap without harming the aluminum any and the tap just falls out. This won\'t help you any in this case, but maybe in the future.
bruski